When growth becomes a Tax Liability Risk for Recruitment Agencies
Recruitment growth brings opportunity, but also tax risk. From April 2026, JSL rules may expose agencies to unpaid umbrella PAYE and NI liabilities. Tax Liability Insurance can help mitigate identified risks and protect business value as you grow.
Chantal Disbrowe

When growth becomes a Tax Liability Risk for Recruitment Agencies
In the world of building a successful recruitment business, growth is typically a good thing and the mark of success, but in some cases, growth can deliver additional risks and liabilities. This would certainly be the case for employment businesses supplying temporary labour.
Legislation changes in April 2026 has introduced Joint and Several Liability (JSL) rules whereby HMRC now has the legal power to transfer the liability for unpaid PAYE income tax and national insurance contributions from the Umbrella company directly to the agency.
JSL across an increasing workforce (even with a relatively small exposure), has now become a significant financial risk agencies need to manage.
When growth multiplies the exposure
Consider an agency that has increased its contingent workforce from 100 to 250 workers.
With the approximate weekly tax exposure for 100 workers estimated at around c.£25,000, scaling this (conservatively) up to 250 workers could see the agency exposed to a tax liability under JSL in the region of £3 million.
And that's before considering any potential interest, penalties or other associated costs (which is dependent on the circumstances) that HMRC could impose.
This is where tax risk can become a balance-sheet issue, a growth issue and ultimately a transaction issue. The challenge isn't necessarily identifying the risk. The real question is:
“What can the business do about it?”
We have highlighted how growth can change the nature of the tax risk a business can face. But what can a business do to help protect against this risk? That’s where Orbio comes in. Our specialist Tax Liability Insurance was designed to mitigate the tax risk JSL has created.
As businesses scale, tax positions can become increasingly significant. What was initially considered relatively low risk, may attract much greater attention once the organisation has a substantial workforce, a larger turnover or becomes the subject of investment or acquisition. For an ambitious business, the issue isn't simply the tax risk itself. It's the scale of the exposure created by growth.
Tax Liability Insurance can change the conversation
Tax Liability Insurance from Orbio can provide a way to mitigate a specific, identified tax risk.
Rather than allowing a potential but significant exposure to hit the balance sheet or become a sticking point, insurance can potentially turn an uncertain future tax liability into a known insurance policy cost.
A typical policy providing £3m of Tax Liability cover for 250 workers would cost an agency approximately 41 pence per worker, per week.
That can provide greater confidence for businesses, investors, buyers, sellers and their advisers alike.
Benefits of Tax liability Insurance from Orbio?
1. Known Cost: Orbio converts an uncertain tax exposure into an affordable insurance policy cost, making the financial risk easier to quantify.
2. Provides protection of value: Orbio helps protect the value created by growth from a potential tax liability.
3. Helps Manage business scale: Where a growing business is faced with a possible but significant exposure, insurance can provide a mechanism for addressing the aggregate risk.
4. Allows for better use of capital: Depending on the circumstances, insurance may reduce the need to retain capital or provisions against a contingent tax exposure. This can allow a business’s capital to remain focused on continued growth.
5. Supports business negotiation/ acquisition: Where a known tax risk could otherwise delay an acquisition, investment or disposal, insurance can provide a practical mechanism to mitigate the risk.
It is likely that a buyer will look more favourably on a business that works with SafeRec accredited Umbrella companies and then also has a Tax Liability policy in place.
Neither party wants a potentially issue to undermine the value or timing of the deal and so Tax Liability Insurance works to shift this mindset to the benefit of both the buyer and seller.
The bigger the workforce, the bigger the potential exposure
This is an important consideration for businesses experiencing rapid growth. The financial exposure can increase with every new worker. That means tax risk shouldn't necessarily be viewed in isolation.
A £500 or £1,000 potential exposure may look relatively modest when considered against a single worker. However, multiplied across 500, 1,000 or 5,000 workers, the numbers begin to look very different. Growth can magnify both the value of a business and the financial consequences if HMRC were to investigate or transfer tax liability under JSL.
That's why identifying and managing tax risk early can be particularly important for businesses preparing for their next stage of growth, investment or a potential transaction.
Tax Liability Insurance as a growth and transaction tool
Tax Liability Insurance isn't about simply protecting against something that might happen. It’s about answering the question of how a business is prepared to respond to the potential risk.
No one buys Health Insurance hoping they will one day need to make a claim, it’s key purpose is to be a valuable safety net should the unexpected arise. The same fundamental principle of future security should also apply when considering Tax Liability Insurance for business protection.
Where there is a specific, identified tax risk, insurance can potentially provide a manageable and quantifiable cost. Which is also surprisingly affordable.
For a growing business, that can mean greater assurance.
For a business preparing for investment or sale, it can potentially help protect value and remove an obstacle from the transaction.
And for buyers, it can provide another mechanism for managing an identified risk.
Protecting your business
At Orbio, we help businesses and their advisers explore how Tax Liability Insurance can be used to manage identified risks; Particularly where the potential exposure has increased alongside the business.
For more information, speak to our expert advisors to discuss how Tax Liability Insurance from Orbio can help protect your business’s future growth.
This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal, tax or insurance advice. Insurance cover is subject to the applicable policy wording, terms, conditions, limits and exclusions. Businesses should obtain appropriate professional advice before making decisions about tax liability, compliance or insurance.