Insurance

Protecting Your Agency with Industry Leading Due Diligence & Insurance

Discover how recruitment agencies can strengthen compliance and protect against tax liabilities by combining SafeRec-certified umbrella companies with specialist Tax Liability Insurance from Orbio.

Chantal Disbrowe's avatar

Chantal Disbrowe

article cover image

Protecting Your Agency with Industry Leading Due Diligence & Insurance

63 SafeRec Certified Umbrella Companies + Tax Liability Insurance from Orbio: Two Layers of Risk Management for Your Recruitment Agency.

**Your choice of umbrella company could do more than strengthen your compliance. **

The recruitment industry is entering a new era of accountability. With JSL changing the way tax risk is managed across labour supply chains, recruitment agencies can no longer afford to take a passive approach to umbrella compliance.

The consequences of an umbrella company failing to correctly account for and make payment of PAYE and National Insurance Contributions (NICs) has the potential to financially expose recruitment agencies further up the supply chain.

So, what can agencies do?

The answer is to combine independently verified compliance with specialist financial protection. And there is an opportunity for agencies to do exactly that by working with one of the 63 SafeRec certified umbrella companies and arranging Tax Liability Insurance through Orbio Insurance.

SafeRec Certification: Compliance you can evidence

Not all umbrella accreditations or certifications offer the same level of assurance. There has been a lot of articles recently implying that you can (or can’t) buy a badge, certificate or accreditation.

SafeRec has developed a certification process designed to provide agencies with genuine visibility of what is happening inside an umbrella company's payroll operation. Rather than relying solely on documentation, promises or occasional compliance checks, SafeRec's certification combines independent legal and operational reviews with ongoing, real-time payroll auditing. This is not a one-off review; it is an ongoing monthly process that is completed consistently, every month without fail.

This certification method encompasses the following 5 key steps:

  1. Legal and operational due diligence: An in-depth review of the umbrella company's contracts, ownership, policies and procedures by WTT Legal, a regulated UK law firm.
  2. Real-time payroll auditing: Payslips are audited directly from the umbrella company's payroll software.
  3. HMRC cross-referencing: Payroll information is checked against Real Time Information (RTI) submissions and HMRC records.
  4. Verification of tax payments: Monthly checks of the umbrella company's HMRC tax account help verify that reported taxes have been paid.
  5. Transparent reporting: Agencies receive monthly audit reports, providing an ongoing evidence trail of payroll compliance.

This is a significant step forward from traditional due diligence. It means agencies can make informed supply chain decisions based on independently verified information, rather than simply accepting assurances from their umbrella providers.

With 63 certified umbrella companies currently listed on the SafeRec website (as at 11th November 2026), agencies have a choice of providers while maintaining a stronger approach to compliance.

Evidencing Supply Chain Compliance is Only One Part

Even the strongest compliance processes cannot guarantee that an agency will never face an HMRC investigation or tax liability challenge.

That is an important distinction.

SafeRec provides the ongoing verification and evidence that agencies need to understand and monitor their umbrella supply chains. However, if an HMRC investigation results in a liability being transferred to an agency, having a robust compliance process does not automatically remove the financial exposure.

This is where Orbio can help.

Orbio: Adding Financial Protection to Compliance Assurance

Tax Liability insurance available through Orbio has been developed specifically for the recruitment and payroll sector, addressing the financial risks created by umbrella reform and JSL.

Through its partnership with SafeRec, Orbio offers recruitment agencies the opportunity to combine SafeRec certified umbrella compliance with specialist Tax Liability Insurance.

The solution is straightforward:

  1. Use a SafeRec Certified umbrella company.
  2. Benefit from independently verified payroll compliance.
  3. Finally, consider arranging a Tax Liability Insurance policy through Orbio for additional financial protection.

Orbio's Tax Liability insurance is underwritten in the Lloyd's market and is designed to provide protection against qualifying tax liabilities arising from umbrella supplier risks (subject to the policy's terms, conditions, limits and exclusions).

This gives agencies two complementary layers of protection:

Blog Post Pic 2.jpg

Neither replaces the other. Together, they offer a much stronger approach to managing supply chain risk.

Why JSL Makes This So Important

Under the new PAYE rules that came into effect from 6 April 2026, HMRC can pursue an agency or other relevant party in the labour supply chain for qualifying unpaid PAYE liabilities arising from an umbrella company's failure.

For recruitment agencies, this fundamentally changes the risk calculation.

An umbrella failure could potentially become an agency's financial problem.

Consider the implications:

  • A substantial unexpected tax bill.
  • Significant pressure on cash flow and working capital.
  • Legal and professional costs associated with HMRC investigations and disputes.
  • Disruption to client relationships and ongoing recruitment operations.
  • Potential reputational damage.

Even agencies that have invested heavily in due diligence and compliance need to consider what happens if something goes wrong. The question is no longer simply whether you trust your umbrella provider. It is whether your business has considered how it would manage the financial impact if that trust is ever tested.

You Don't Have to Choose Between Compliance and Insurance

One of the biggest advantages of this approach is that agencies can strengthen their existing umbrella supply chain without treating compliance and insurance as separate challenges. By selecting from the SafeRec Certified umbrella directory, agencies can access providers operating within an independently monitored compliance framework. By arranging an appropriate insurance policy through Orbio, they may be able to take the additional step of protecting their own balance sheet against specified tax liabilities, subject to the policy terms. And importantly, this is not about replacing good due diligence with insurance.

It is about recognising that responsible risk management requires:

  • Knowing who you are working with
  • Verifying their compliance
  • Monitoring their payroll continuously
  • Keeping all evidence
  • Protecting your business financially

That is the approach we believe agencies should consider in the new JSL landscape.

Take The Next Step: Find Out More about SafeRec and Orbio

The recruitment industry needs to raise its standards. Responsible agencies should not be left carrying the financial consequences of poor practices elsewhere in the supply chain.

Working with a SafeRec Certified umbrella company is an important step towards greater transparency and accountability.

Arranging Tax Liability Insurance through Orbio may be a further step towards protecting your business financially.

63 SafeRec Certified umbrella companies. One stronger approach to compliance. An additional layer of financial protection for your agency.

Don't wait until HMRC comes knocking to discover the limits of your protection.

Check the SafeRec Certified Umbrella Directory and contact Orbio Insurance to discuss whether Tax Liability Insurance may be suitable for your agency.

SafeRec provides independent compliance verification and reporting. Tax Liability Insurance is a separate insurance product, subject to eligibility, underwriting, policy terms, conditions, limits and exclusions. SafeRec Certification does not itself guarantee freedom from tax liability or automatically provide insurance cover.